Lots of small cities, even smaller towns, have one of those bands. They pull up at the local bar and wow the few who pay attention. They soundtrack the hook-ups and break-ups of their friend groups in backyards and at bonfires. They’re going to be huge. Most of these bands never made it. DeYarmond Edison, first of Eau Claire, Wisconsin, and then briefly of the (still undersung) indie hothouse Raleigh—well, they almost did. Instead, they imploded. The difference between them and the rest is what’s next: From the ashes of DeYarmond Edison rose the shape-shifting emo-psych of Bon Iver and the psych-folk of Megafaun, two of the 21st century’s crucial rock bands.
The box set Epoch archives this for posterity in five LPs, four CDs, and a deeply intimate and gratifyingly detailed book by the set’s executive producer, the journalist (and longtime friend of the band) Grayson Haver Currin. It all charts childhood buddies Brad Cook, Phil Cook, Justin Vernon, and Joe Westerlund as they quickly transcend their influences and learn—in various combinations of solo and group recordings—who they are and what they can do.